Is sin dead? No, not by a long shot. Yet as Easter approaches, some pastors and theologians worry: How can Christians celebrate Jesus’ atonement for their sins and the promise of eternal life in his resurrection if they don’t recognize themselves as sinners?
Has the ‘notion of sin’ been lost? – USATODAY.com
One certainly hopes so. We need a system of ethics that the whole world can agree on, not one that’s based on negative reinforcement — and that obviously doesn’t work.
The concept of sin as punishment is similar to the parent who makes dire threats if misbehavior continues, yet never follows through. It doesn’t take a child (or adult) with any brains at all long enough to figure out that nothing’s likely to happen.
That is not conducive to good behavior. One has to be really frightened to base one’s conduct on the threat of punishment that no one can prove exists.
When people understand that being nice to others is to their own advantage, then we will have the basis of an ethical code for the ages. Forbidding people to “sin” while condoning — for example — war and the destruction of the ecosystem isn’t fooling anyone. “Do as I say, not as I do” has never been very useful advice.